Gotta Empty Out the Inside of My Head

Engaged in the annual springtime delusion that I’m going to turn my 2.5-mile regular power walk into a jog. (Don’t be too impressed – so far that means that I walk up the hills and run down them.) I have an iPod playlist just for this purpose, and it doesn’t contain anything that comes close to the music I work with for a living. The purpose is to deactivate my left brain and provide an irresistible groove. A tight rhythm section, some good acoustic guitar or piano, lyrics that make me smile. The perfect spring-cleaning song in today’s shuffle – Inside Of My Head (David Wilcox).

The Bassi Speak

A comment posted on this blog a week or so ago:

“A question for you about us big, heavy voices that take years to develop – how do you recommend we find opportunities? I’m a basso profundo, so I’m looking at just hitting my stride in my late 20’s. Of course, when you’re 30 it’s too late to win a Met competition, and young artist programs still seem to have this prejudice for younger instruments. But the rungs of this business are set up for people to finish their degree(s), hit the YA circuit, and then try for covers or comprimari – and it seems beyond the pale for some companies that a singer might miss a rung or two.So what’s a low bass to do? How do we deal with the “end of the great big American voice” syndrome?”

I polled some of my favorite basses. Here’s a composite response.


Music schools are a great umbrella protecting a young bass from the “real” world. (NOTE: a bass is still “young” in his late twenties!) You can build up a lot of concert, recital, as well as operatic repertoire, all under the watchful eye of your “team” of teachers and coaches.

Find a way to extend the schooling — you’ll always be a commodity if you’re a low bass at a school, and it’s a lot of fun being needed (more fun than being one of every bass in New York, 20 to 75 years old, auditioning for the same role).

Find a degree program that won’t require a loan and then revel in that program’s offerings; stretch out the time — it’s not a race to get out, particularly for a bass. You’ll get more stage time (invaluable, in my opinion) and more studio time.


Create opportunities to sing in any capacity wherever possible. For me, the greatest benefit came from singing outreach/runout shows for a local opera company for a number of years while in my twenties. I proved to myself that I could sing in the morning, and it provided a daily dosage of excited, energetic audience of elementary school students. There is no better way to develop the voice than to use it every day! And there is also no better way to get comfortable onstage than to sing a lot, particularly when the role is in English.


This country has seen an enormous surge of young artist programs in the last decade, and just about all of them will be looking for a bass each year.

Many YAPs have a prejudice for younger instruments, but I promise that a bass that sings consistently through his natural vocal range could just about write his ticket into any program he chooses.

Be smart about finding YA programs that actually put their YA’s on stage in smaller roles. Granted, sometimes having to do your 14th performance of Ceprano sucks big time, especially if you consider Sparafucile and Sarastro more up your alley. But being a bass “saved my ass,” because I would have absolutely HATED doing all that language work, music study, role memorization, movement and acting work, etc., and only occasionally put it to test. Even in the smallest roles, at least I was on stage constantly through my 20’s.

A young bass is actually at an advantage. Even if you are miles away from your “prime” there are a million roles you could do.

Young basso profundi (as well as dramatic types) presumably already have a sizable voice, even if it’s rough around the edges. For that type of voice, it would seem logical to look at young artist programs that are attached to big houses (“big” as in “cavernous auditorium”) and who look to the young artists for actual mainstage work (generally to save money). If (again presuming a future “dramatic” singer already has a large, if unhewn, voice) these companies do in fact use their young artists on the main stage, they would love to save money by using a young basso as a second armored man or as one of the 25 bass comprimario roles in a Verdi opera. If you have a loud voice and a middle C, you’re on.

The Met Competition

I wouldn’t worry about the Met competitions, unless you are a once-in-a-lifetime voice. The cutoff age of 30 is just about impossible for a bass to truly compete with other voice types. To start with, the bass repertoire has very few show-stopping arias compared to any of the other voice types, so you have that working against you, too!


Take any greatest hits operas and I’ll show you how many roles for bass there are, smallest to biggest… just off the top of my head: Rigoletto has Ceprano, Marullo, Sparafucile… Traviata has the “Cena e pronta” guy, the Doctor, Marquis and Baron… Flute: Armored Guy, Sprecher, Sarastro (more and more Papageno too these days)… Nozze di Figaro: Antonio, Bartolo, Figaro… Don G: Masetto, Commendatore, Leporello, Don Giovanni… Romeo has Capulet and Friar… Boheme has Benoit, Alcindoro, Colline (sometimes Schaunard)… Don Carlo has at least 2 bass roles smaller than Phiilip, Tanhaeuser has 2 smaller than Landgraf, Sampson has 2 mid sized roles, Midsummer has 3 smaller than Bottom… anyway, you get my point.

USUALLY the smaller roles can be done with ANY type of bass, be it “profundo” or cantante or bass/bari or buffo or whatever… additionally, they can almost ALL be sung by a bass in his “natural” voice (as compared to the small roles for tenor, which tend to be pretty “sprech-y” and “barky” right?)

In virtually any given season at virtually any given opera company, I PROMISE there are more good-singing small opportunities for young basses than for any other young voice type.

The Buffo Question

Another option would be to embrace stage craft and dive into some character stuff. This basically requires the ability to let go of the thought that every sound a bass makes has to sound like Kurt Moll — if you’re 25, it’s okay to sound 25. And, if you’re singing Bartolo, it’s okay to not sound gloriously Rene Pape-like on your high e’s. Figure out how to lighten up and sing up to an e, and buffo is a cakewalk.

In the young artist world there aren’t any old basses around to sing the buffo stuff. If a company’s gonna perform Don Pasquale, then some young singer is gonna have to don some aging make-up. If they’re gonna do Barber of Seville, someone’s putting on a fat suit. May as well be you — you’ll be making money while being on stage.

If you can follow a conductor while singing patter, you can follow a conductor anytime. Now, most basses tremble at the thought of being pigeon-holed and labeled “buffo,” but if this you’re an actual profundo, ain’t nobody gonna care if you did a Pasquale in Des Moines when you were 25.


Consider yourself lucky that you have a rare voice type. If you can make it through the “growing pains” of the voice type, then your chances for a career are better than most. Find a good teacher, be a good colleague, learn languages, study music/art, and get onstage as much as possible. Understand that life, like singing, is simply a “work in progress”.

Laying Low

Thanks, guys. Love having other people do my work for me.

Expect a few weeks with pretty lame blog content. I’m a little fried. Putting one foot in front of the other, trying to carve a few work-free hours out of every day, knowing that I have about 6 weeks to recharge before the summer steamroller hits me.


Luxie P.

Can I just make a comment about the age/later-maturing voice thing?

Aside from the eternal “Why are men grumbling about OPPORTUNITIES – try being a soprano!” kvetch, I would like to point out that some of the points made ALSO apply to soprani with larger and/or later developing voices.

In an era of “the younger the better” and having to compete for YAP slots with 22 year old adorably cute soprani, it is helpful to note that larger voices that haven’t matured enough to GET HIRED in their target fach can also follow the bass path…supporting roles!

Small roles like Ceprano (la femme!) have been very helpful to me in learning the basics of my craft, and working out my vocal/artistic bugs, while still having something on my resume. Not to mention, smaller, shorter roles are a LOT less stressful when you’re at a point where you’re still having to concentrate on your technique.

Unless yoone is truly an older singer whose voice is actually matured and trained, one shouldn’t expect to burst out the gate singing Tosca first thing.

I think some singers may feel there is a stigma in singing supporting roles, but really! As you pointed out, if the voice is together, and if it’s all that, no one is going to give two hoots if you sang The Third Maid from the Right of the Fifth Courtier at the Podunk Opera.

Just my $.25.


Regarding the development of young basses, it is worth noting the meteoric rise of Robert Gleadow and Robert Pomakov, two very fine young Canadian basses who were both well-developed enough vocally and artistically to be launched upon international careers in their early twenties.


I would like to note that world famous baritone Leo Nucci sang in the La Scala chorus until his mid-thirties and that Met Baritone Tim Noble started his graduate work at Indiana University at the age of 32. What links both is that they got lots of stage time doing other things beside lead roles in opera and both ended up singing leads around the world for over 30 years. There is no rush. Just keep on singing.

Add Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to Blog